![]() I suggest that it deserves respect and acceptance for what it is: imperfect but our own." "It may not be a perfect heritage - I'm not suggesting it is - but it is ours. "If we are to become engrossed in the idea that we must at all times be correctly modern, we lose a part of our heritage," Fraser said in a recent speech to the Red Chamber. O Canada lyric change bill, C-210, approved by Senate committeeįraser, a journalist and editor appointed by former prime minister Jean Chrétien in 1998, said it is a dangerous precedent to start fiddling with lyrics written by a man long dead."The Senate should not be reticent in defending and preserving the heritage of Canada." Our history means nothing in this country anymore, and it's a shame that we're doing this," he said in an interview with CBC News. "If we are constantly revising everything because it was written in another generation, our national symbols will have no value. While others, including Conservative Nova Scotia Senator Michael MacDonald, have said the "sloppy" legislation should be defeated in its present form because it's simply an attempt to sanitize a national symbol. The bill's backers, including Liberal MP Greg Fergus, hope to see the bill passed into law in time for Canada's 150th birthday celebrations on July 1. As per the Senate's procedural policy, debate on the bill can be continually adjourned by critics, punting a vote on the matter to a later date. Nearly a year later, the bill is now in its last legislative phase - third reading in the Senate - awaiting a final vote. Some notable female Tory MPs, including Michelle Rempel and Lisa Raitt, backed Bélanger's bill. The bill passed in the House of Commons largely along party lines, with all Liberal and NDP MPs voting in favour of the changes, while most Conservatives opposed. MacDonaldīélanger, who passed away last summer after a battle with ALS, sought to make the anthem gender-neutral by removing the phrase "all thy sons command" and replacing it with "all of us command." "Politicians are not usually poets." 'Everybody knows the tragedy of Bélanger's circumstances, a very tragic thing - but, with respect, it's the government that treated it like the Children's Wish Foundation.' - Conservative Senator Michael L. "It's a fine example of what happens when you let politicians meddle," she said of Bill C-210 to amend the National Anthem Act. Liberal Senator Joan Fraser, a self-described "ardent feminist," said the new phrasing is both grammatically incorrect and a misguided attempt to make the song reflect "today's values." Some members of the Senate are determined to stop Parliament from changing the words of the national anthem, with one senator deriding the late Liberal MP Mauril Bélanger's proposed amendments to O Canada as "clunky, leaden and pedestrian."
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |